Pepys’ guilty pleasure

The library contains one of the largest bound collections of 17th-century French fashion prints in the world. Avidon, a PhD researcher at Christ’s College, Cambridge, focuses on two of its volumes, the Habits de France and Modes de Paris, which comprise over a hundred fashion illustrations printed between 1670 and 1696.

Appearing in the journal The Seventeenth Century, Avidon’s article publishes eight images from the collection for the first time. Avidon links one of these images to a cringe-worthy episode in Pepys’ diary.

In 1669, Pepys wrote that he was ‘afeared to be seen’ in a summer suit he had just bought ‘because it was too fine with the gold lace at the hands’. Finally he plucked up the courage but a socially superior colleague spotted him in the park and told him the sleeves were above his station. Pepys decided ‘never to appear in Court’ with the sleeves and made a tailor cut them off, ‘as it is fit I should.’

Pepys learnt a lesson that day but this didn’t put him off fashion. He went on to buy a print entitled ‘Habit Noir’ (evening wear) which shows an elite Frenchman proudly showing off very similar lace cuffs as well as plentiful ribbons.

“Pepys would have seen this outfit as pretty risky,” Marlo Avidon said. “This was for a French courtier, and was probably well beyond his budget. But Pepys probably did own suits with these kinds of ribbon loops, just not so many as this. This is how fashion worked and still works today – you demonstrate your knowledge of style within your means.”

“Pepys felt he had to walk a really fine line, especially early in his career. His father was a tailor, his mother a washerwoman, and throughout his life Pepys was profoundly worried about how he was perceived and took steps to manage his image. The diary shows his anxieties as a young adult. The prints show that his determination to prove himself, using clothes and cultural capital, continued throughout his life.”

Pepys rose to be the Chief Secretary to the Admiralty in 1673 and was first elected as an MP in 1679.

Pepys’ initial print purchases and close observation of his superiors in the civil service, detailed in his diary, show him attempting to access lofty social circles, Avidon argues. But as Pepys expanded his print collection, he was part of a network of gentleman scholars linked to the Naval Office and Royal Society.

“He started to use fashion to solidify his social position and demonstrate his cosmopolitan tastes,” Avidon said, “but collecting fashion prints was also a way to cement intellectual relationships and maintain his scholarly reputation.”

“I went into this research with a lot of reservations about Pepys, I didn't like him. But the prints offer a much more nuanced picture of him, a more human picture. He was fallible and anxious and his actions in response to that anxiety feel quite familiar today.”

Avidon’s research suggests that Pepys never shook off his worries about dressing inappropriately, making a fashion faux pas, or the moral dilemma of wearing designs imported from France.

“There was concern about the relationship Charles II was fostering with the Catholic French King Louis XIV and about growing French influence on English culture. This created a sense of moral crisis. There was particular anxiety in England about Popery and its association with vanity,” Avidon said.

French clothes were often viewed in England as being scandalously excessive as they combined luxury silks with over-the-top trim and lace, and huge statement accessories.

_{Image: Antoine Trouvain, Femme de qualité en deshabille negligé, etching, 1695. This print depicts an elite French woman wearing informal lounge wear. She appears to be in the process of getting ready in her boudoir. She holds a necklace and wears a headdress made from stiffened lace, and a luxurious night gown inspired by Asian textiles.}

“Pepys had a French wife, was friends with French merchants and had a keen interest in French culture,” Avidon said. “But Pepys also ridiculed people returning from France wearing over-the-top French fashions and he had a preoccupation with French elites being frivolous.”

“Pepys felt under pressure to maintain the moral high ground, not just by wearing clothes appropriate for his own social station but also to uphold what was appropriate for his country morally and economically.”

In his diary, Pepys condemned the English Queen’s Maids of Honour for wearing French-inspired masculine-inspired riding habits, writing ‘nobody could take them for women in any point whatever – which was an odde sight, and a sight did not please me.’

A year earlier, however, he thought the opposite, noting ‘it was pretty to see the young pretty ladies dressed like men’. And Pepys later purchased a French print showing an evolved version of this style featuring a martial style coat.

“When it came to women’s clothes, Pepys’ taste and attitudes were constantly changing and often conflicting,” Avidon said.

When viewed together, Pepys’ diary and print collection emphasise that women bore the brunt of accusations of vanity and excessive consumption but fashion still remained a very masculine concern in this period.

Pepys’ French wife Elizabeth died in 1669, aged 29, shortly before Pepys started collecting his fashion prints.

“Pepys’ diary suggests he really loved his wife and he wanted her to dress well,” Avidon said. “But he worried about her overspending on clothes and sometimes went shopping with her. Pepys kept Elizabeth in a state of fashion limbo as he did himself.”

References in Pepys’ diary suggest that Elizabeth was interested in prints herself and Avidon believes that she influenced what Pepys went on to collect.

Elizabeth died soon after a trip with Pepys’ to Paris in May 1669. We don’t know much about their stay but they almost certainly shopped for prints – because Pepys’ friend John Evelyn advised him on how to do it – and perhaps clothes too.

“Pepys was distraught by Elizabeth’s death,” Avidon said. “I think these prints of fashionable young women must have reminded Pepys of Elizabeth. The collection could be seen as an homage to her.”

Pepys soon employed a teenage housekeeper, Mary Skinner, who swiftly became his mistress. They stayed together until his death and she was often referred to as Mrs Pepys. We know very little about Mary but Avidon believes that the print collection could bring us much closer to her.

Pepys took a leading role in Mary’s education, moulding her as a refined gentlewoman as he had Elizabeth, and Avidon suggests that he may have given Mary black and white fashion prints to colour.

“Some of the prints were clearly not professionally coloured, they look amateurish,” Avidon said. “Pepys acquired these prints over the course of his relationship with Mary. It’s quite possible that he was teaching her how to colour these prints. We’ll never know for sure, but by the time Mary died, she had become a fairly fashionable woman in her own right.”